Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Why do people "think' that they'll need a survival longarm?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Why do people "think' that they'll need a survival longarm?

    and then ALSO "think" that it wont be shtf/combat? You aint gonna benefit from having a longarm cause you're lost, hurt, sick, etc. A personal locator beacon and rental satellite phone, are much less money, weight, bulk and will be a lot more likely to save you. WHY would you need to forage animal food and other people NOT need to do so? If they DO, there will be plenty of them within ear shot of your location and plenty of them will shoot you on sight, cause it'll be shtf. The reason guys dont want to think like this is they aint skilled/capable enough. So they just jump over the need for combat capability. They dont want to have to lug around the extra weight/bulk of such guns, gear and ammo, and they dont want to train at such things. No bird is worth a shotshell in a shtf situation, and it's certainly not worth the risk you run of having enemies hear your shot and then all you have to fight with is a shotgun, which sucks at the job if they know to stay 50m away and use cover. 50m is still a snap shot to hit your (cover using) head with a silenced .22lr autorifle. They dont want to have to aim swiftly. That's why they favor the shotgun. it's not about slugs. If they were concerned about single-projectile accuracy, they'd have been training with a silenced shorty AR and .22lr conversion unit, costing 1/3rd as much.

    Another reason why guys dont want to consider this is they want to use .45 and or 308, for men and "big game". If you're so remote that you have a chance at big animals, ten you can also use night vision, active and passive IR scope, and BAIT to get within 100m of such game and brain them at night with a 223 softpoint. Such a hit will drop anything short of elephant. Such a setup will let you brain deer, hogs, pronghorn at 50m or less with the BB gun quiet subsonic 22. Such is a lot easier of course, to use on cattle, horses, domestic hogs. Small game doesn't give you enough calories to justify a 12 ga blast, weight, bulk either. A cottontail is 500 calories. a squirrel 400. a grouse 250 calories, a snow shoe hare 700 calories. A turkey is easily taken at longer range with a silenced .22lr conversion unit than with a shotgun. The thick feathers mean that you must aim birdshot at their-heads/necks. With a riot barrel, that means 25m or less. Buckshot wont extend that range much, either. A tight choke or Vang barrel just means that the shotgun has only 3" of pattern spread at 10m, so you'll still have to aim it as you would a rifle. So how is that a help?

    So forget the shotgun, or the rifle/shotgun combo guns, or the muzzleloaders. Get the Mini-14 and .22lr "how to make a silencer" books from Amazon. a day-night scope, nvd goggle, and have a EFFECTIVE setup for shtf. The Mini14 is a crap basis for a silencer. The info, tho, is easily extrapolated to make a can for the AR-15. The mini-14 book is long out of print and even when it was in print., people were asking ridiculous prices for it, as in over $1000. I've never understood how they could be thinking that, and I wrote those books. I also wrote the .45 book.





  • #2
    Because there are a lot of bad people out there and in a WROL situation it is every man for himself. The firearms that you choose should fit the terrain that you will live in and be functional throughout a 365 day temperature change in that area. Reliability is "Job 1", for the firearms that you choose. Choosing firearms from some apocalyptic fantasy story that you read about is a bad move.

    Comment


    • #3
      We have firearms because we enjoy shooting. Everything from adult precision air rifles and pistols to .300 win mag. As no one lives within a mile of us, we shoot here. I reload because I enjoy it.
      If we'd need meat, I can easily shoot a deer, turkey or go fishing.. Same as almost everywhere else, there are feral hogs in the swamp land a few miles from here.
      We live about 17 miles from the nearest small (under 9K pop) town on a dirt road in the Chattahoochee NF. Our TV is satellite as is our internet. As there is no cell service here, our phone is VOIP. I'm certain others are urban, suburban and a lot even more remote than us.
      Everyone's situation is different.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Garand View Post
        Because there are a lot of bad people out there and in a WROL situation it is every man for himself. The firearms that you choose should fit the terrain that you will live in and be functional throughout a 365 day temperature change in that area. Reliability is "Job 1", for the firearms that you choose. Choosing firearms from some apocalyptic fantasy story that you read about is a bad move.
        This is very true. While there are firearms that fit almost every location or scenario, they may not fit yours. A thorough study of your area, including both, your primary operating area and a possible secondary location (generally called a bugout location) should be undertaken before a final decision on what firearms you should buy, and where you should keep them.

        Personally, I can't think of any location or scenario where a long gun wouldn't play a part, but I haven't been in a lot of places, so I would be unqualified to make such a statement.


        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by TRex2 View Post
          Personally, I can't think of any location or scenario where a long gun wouldn't play a part, but I haven't been in a lot of places, so I would be unqualified to make such a statement.
          To add to your comment about long guns; here, the forest is very dense. Unless one is hunting the power line clear cuts, long range capability is not as important as in other locations.

          I have a RWS Diana M48, it's a 22 caliber adult precision air (springer) rifle with a 3x9 Leapers optic. The accuracy of the adult precision air rifles is impressive..
          Although not what I consider a choice for a WROL or a BOL. It is an excellent tool for harvesting birds, rabbits, squirrels etc. with a minimum of damage to the meat. We have acorns and hazelnuts both attract deer and squirrels; so a deer caliber for deer and an air rifle for squirrels.

          Bugout locations would be an interesting topic.




          Comment


          • #6
            While it is not a true long gun...I verily enjoy shooting my Thompson Contender and have five different barrels in different calibrations for it.

            One of which I manufacture my own ammo as it is not common place even in better stocked gun stores..7mm TCU.

            I enjoy sitting down and taking my time with this handgun ...and making it count...accuracy...versus just making a lot of noise.
            Also and though it is a single action trigger.this pistol has one of the finest triggers I've ever experienced. It has become a standard by which I measure trigger pulls on a firearm. A good trigger pull can spoil you.


            Also ...like some...I enjoy my time at the reloading bench as much as I do shooting.....go figure..


            Orangetom
            Not an Ishmaelite

            Comment


            • #7
              So wrong! Having survived 2 wars in actual combat an hunted for 54 years, I believe you are WRONG! Yes a .22 has its place taking small game is its job. To shoot a deer with a .22 a 40 gram bullet tells me you have not been in combat or hunted very much. When doing either you need the mass, energy, and weight of the round to penetrate upon hitting the target. The faster the round the less deviation of it's flight path. So it's more accurate.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by RICHFL View Post
                So wrong! Having survived 2 wars in actual combat an hunted for 54 years, I believe you are WRONG! Yes a .22 has its place taking small game is its job. To shoot a deer with a .22 a 40 gram bullet tells me you have not been in combat or hunted very much. When doing either you need the mass, energy, and weight of the round to penetrate upon hitting the target. The faster the round the less deviation of it's flight path. So it's more accurate.
                He hasn't but he's "thought about it"a lot.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Also what someone like GunKid calls hunting most of us refer to it as poaching or unethical hunting.

                  In a true survival situation I can very well understand using what you have and of course improvising.

                  However willingly starting out with a minimal amount of gear that also performs in a minimal fashion gives away a minimal thought process.
                  ​​​​​​​

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    A lot of stuff floating around in this thread.

                    first, what is the survival situation being discussed:

                    end of civilization?
                    natural disaster?
                    lost in the woods?

                    starting with lost in the woods:

                    you should always have a few basic items anytime you are in the woods. First and foremost is your cell phone. Even without coverage, the GPS should work. It can also be used as a signal mirror, and signal light. Next is a first aid kit that includes a clotting agent and bandages. Not band aids, those they should be in the kit as well. There’s a number of trauma kits that will fit in a small space out there.
                    Water. More is better. A small knife, and fire making ability. A side arm, rifle, or both. An EPRB is a nice to have item. They run about $300 US, or they did last time I looked. They do exactly one thing, call in search and rescue. Every five years they need to be sent in for a battery replacement and certification.
                    a jacket slightly heavier than the weather suggests.

                    obviously, all this goes in a day pack (or bigger - I have a day pack and a large pack I use for hunting, depending on the species. Sitka flash 20 and a Mystery Ranch Beartooth 80)

                    somebody should know where you are going and when to expect you back.

                    a map and compass is worth carrying.

                    natural disaster

                    if we are staying at home, then it’s a matter of food, shelter, light, security, and first aid. If we are bugging out, then all the gear from our time in the woods, plus:

                    food - freeze dried and easy to store and prepare items. Plan on two weeks worth
                    money - you should have emergency cash set aside.

                    clothing - you need to consider your climate and the worst set of conditions you will face.
                    shelter - throw your camping gear in the vehicle.
                    firearms

                    this all depends on how much notice, how quickly you can go, and if you’re starting out in a vehicle.

                    end of the world

                    thats a whole thread / forum itself.


                    none of this was meant to be an exhaustive list, but rather food for thought. You’ll have to tailor everything to your situation, location, and budget.
                    Last edited by Dorobuta; 06-03-2021, 11:47 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Why do I need long arms; well, to eat small or big game. A .22 RF or shotgun for small game and rifles for big game.

                      Hopefully, I won't need them to protect us. However, same as auto, health or homeowner's insurance better to have them and not need them, than not to have them and need them. The same applies to firearms.

                      A .22 RF doesn't cut it for all needs.





                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X